Skip to main content
Cases & review processFor both

Understand the review and case process

Follow a review from monitoring through evidence, specialist filing with Amazon, verification, and billing.

10 minute readLast reviewed Reviewed by Customer ExperienceNext review due

From a monitored review to a case

  1. Review Magic scans an active listing according to its monitoring schedule.
  2. New reviews are normalized, and new 1–3-star reviews are checked for supported policy signals.
  3. A potential violation receives a case file with the review text, policy basis, evidence, and proposed wording.
  4. The case queues automatically: subscriptions inside free removal credits and the monthly success-fee cap, Pay Per Removal inside the monthly removal budget. There is nothing to approve. The statuses below show when a case waits and why.
  5. Operations files cases through Amazon’s official process, starting with the reviews most likely to come down, and records the external case reference.
  6. Review Magic waits and checks the source again before recording a removal.

Statuses that may need your action

Customer-action case statuses
StatusMeaningWho can act
Waiting on budgetOn Pay Per Removal, the case is built and needs money consent: set or raise the monthly removal budget. It files automatically as soon as budget allows.Client owner or billing admin. An agency cannot set a client’s budget.
Next in lineThe account has reached its concurrent active-case limit.Usually no action; a slot promotes automatically when another case completes.
Paused by budgetThe monthly removal budget or success-fee cap has no remaining room.Raise it to move sooner. Otherwise, cases waiting to file are re-queued when the month resets, and a removal that is already confirmed is billed once the cap has room.

Statuses handled by Review Magic

Operational case statuses
StatusMeaning
QueuedReady for an operations specialist to claim.
Specialist workingAn operations specialist is reviewing and preparing the filing.
SubmittedThe case was filed and the external reference was recorded.
Verifying removalThe system is checking whether the review still exists.
RemovedA follow-up check confirmed that the review was no longer present.
Not removedThe review remained present or the attempt did not produce a verified removal.
CancelledThe case was withdrawn before submission.
Billing held by agencyThe removal is confirmed, but billing for it is on hold for the linked agency portfolio. Billing resumes automatically when the hold is lifted or the agency link ends.

Hands-off, answered

Do I need to approve anything before you file? No. We find the violation, build the case, and file it, always going after the reviews most likely to come down first.

How do you decide which reviews get appealed? Every flagged review is scored on policy-evidence strength. We work the list from most to least removable. On every plan, choosing among your 1–3-star reviews is our call — that is the point of hands-off.

What do I control, and what will I pay? Pay Per Removal: the monthly removal budget is the ceiling on how many removals we may bill; you pay only for verified removals. Subscriptions: included removals come first, and your plan price is the ceiling unless your cap allows more.

Why does my dashboard show cases I never asked for? Because the work is already done. Cases appear once your account, card, and products are in — from there everything files automatically, and this help center or support can answer anything specific.

Money authority: who sets budgets and fees

Case selection, wording, and filing are handled by Review Magic — no role approves individual cases. The one customer control is money: the monthly removal budget (and any success-fee cap), which only a client owner or billing admin can set or raise.

An agency cannot set or raise a client’s budget or cap, even when a fee delegation is on file. Ordinary operational access does not imply money authority.

How a removal is confirmed

A submitted case does not become a success merely because Amazon accepted the filing. Review Magic performs a later source check and records durable removal evidence only when the review is absent.

Success-fee billing is tied to that confirmed outcome. If a filing does not result in a verified removal, no success fee is charged for the attempted case.

Why timing varies

Catalog size, review volume, case limits, evidence quality, Amazon response behavior, and verification windows all affect timing. Queue position is also isolated by account and safety rules; one large portfolio should not be allowed to erase every other customer’s access to processing.

Use the status and activity history instead of relying on a fixed completion promise. Contact support when a case filed with Amazon has passed the decision window shown on its card, when another status seems stuck, or when the evidence shown is incorrect.

Continue the task

Useful destinations

Related field guides

  1. 01Cases & review processWhich Amazon reviews can be challenged?Understand the difference between a negative opinion and a possible Amazon policy violation, what evidence a case needs, and how Review Magic handles the process.Read guide
  2. 02BillingBilling, success fees, cancellation, and refundsUnderstand subscription charges, included removals, success-fee authorization, cancellation, and billing support.Read guide
  3. 03Agency operationsClient and agency permissionsSee who can operate listings, authorize fees and budgets, manage billing, and revoke agency access.Read guide
  4. 04TroubleshootingTroubleshoot common issuesResolve listing validation, access, processing, notification, and billing problems—and know what to send support.Read guide

Content owner: Customer Experience · Category: Cases & review process

Report unclear or outdated guidance